What Are the Most Popular Engagement Ring Styles That Don’t Inspire Regret?

Engagement rings are a harmonization of personal taste between partners, a testament to their love and promises. The nature of this ring requires careful consideration and may even take months to finalize. Unfortunately, not every decision can stand the test of time, leading to considerable regret among people.

Not even celebrities are exempt from these choices. With Taylor Swift’s recent news of her engagement to Travis Kelce, the whole world is abuzz. Fans and jewelers alike are discussing her new bling. Swift’s influence on trends is undeniable; what she wears today will no doubt affect the choices of countless couples tomorrow. However, as our research reveals, not every popular style endures the test of time.

The Alloy Market recently examined Reddit discussions on engagement rings, analyzing comments containing regret-related keywords such as “regret,” “wish I didn’t get it,” and similar phrases, to determine which diamond shapes and ring styles people most often second-guessed.

The Most Regretted Diamond Shapes

Number one on the list is the Twig & Branch diamond shape, with 58 mentions of regret. This organic and nature-inspired design, while unique, may not stand the test of time in terms of taste and practicality.

Cluster shapes closely follow, receiving 47 mentions. Cluster diamonds, which utilize multiple small stones instead of a single larger one, can be challenging to maintain due to their numerous components. It may give a dazzling look at first, but over time, some wearers regret the lack of a singular focal point.

Others featured on the list included the Hidden Halo (44 mentions), a ring of diamonds set beneath the center stone, and the Split Shank (41 mentions), which features a band split into two strands leading to the diamond. While both are aesthetically pleasing, they can be tricky when it comes to long-term wear and maintenance.

Interestingly, Heart-shaped diamonds (32 mentions) were ranked relatively high on the regret scale. This ultra romantic choice sounds perfect when purchasing, but many later find it difficult to style or too sentimental. At the same time, comments mentioned regrets about Oval (27 mentions) and Emerald (26 mentions) cuts. Trends changing over time or the perceived lack of sparkle of a rounder cut could be the reason for this regret.

The Most Regretted Ring Styles

Buyer’s remorse is not only affected by the diamond shape but also by the overall ring style. Standing at the top of this list is the Halo setting (170 mentions), which features a series of smaller diamonds encircling a larger stone at its center. Although the extra sparkle was a bonus point at first, it might cause inconvenience when wearing or maintaining clothes due to their fine details. 

The Edwardian (151 mentions) and Bezel (141 mentions) styles were close behind. Edwardian rings are sometimes too ornate or too complex to pair with modern fashion, despite their vintage intricacy and charm. Meanwhile, the metal setting around the diamond in the Bezel setting often leads to dissatisfaction because it decreases the stone’s sparkle.

The top 6 are Victorian, Pavé, and Art Deco, which received 136, 135, and 78 mentions, respectively. Beautiful and historically rich as they may be, these designs might be complicated to complement future personal style trends and practical wearability.

Expert Brandon Aversano from The Alloy Market commented on the findings:

“Engagement rings are an important decision, which can sometimes, unfortunately, lead to regret,” said Brandon Aversano, CEO of The Alloy Market, a precious metal buying platform. “If you’re seeking a classic choice, a Round Brilliant or pear-shaped diamond with a Solitaire or Three-stone setting may be what you’re looking for — these have clearly stood the test of time.

“If you are considering other styles, such as Halo, Edwardian, or highly stylized Art Deco rings for their visual appeal, it’s worth also weighing their practicality and maintenance needs.”

He added, “In the end, the perfect ring is the one that represents the personality and lifestyle of the wearer. This data-driven insight would be of great use for those who want to minimize future second thoughts, whether it is the ring’s style or preservation.”

Have gold to sell?

Request a free Alloy Appraisal Kit, ship from home, and receive a same-day offer after appraisal.

SEND MY FREE KIT

Have gold to sell?

Request a free Alloy Appraisal Kit, ship from home, and receive a same-day offer after appraisal.

SEND MY FREE KIT

Celebrity Spotlight: Taylor Swift’s Engagement Ring

In true Taylor Swift fashion, her recent engagement ring has already set off a wave of new trends, reigniting interest in antique diamond cuts. Designed by Kindred Lubeck of Artifex Fine Jewelry in collaboration with Travis Kelce, the ring features a massive old mine brilliant-cut diamond set in a yellow-gold band with a bezel setting. Some experts say the stone may be as large as 10-15 carats. 

Jewelers everywhere have begun chiming in on Taylor’s new sparkle. Ann Grimmett of Jared Jewelers believes the ring has “an heirloom look that is both romantic and dreamy. It’s traditional with a modern flair.”

Others comment on the rarity of Swift’s stone. 

While it’s not confirmed what time period Swift’s specific stone was sourced from, Moses adds that “original stones from this era are extremely rare, in part because as new cutting technologies emerged, older stones were often recut or repurposed.” He adds that a “well-preserved original is something collectors and enthusiasts treasure.” People.

Taylor’s ring is proof that an engagement ring can be both deeply personal and culturally influential. While most of us deciding on a ring will never have to consider the influence Swift has, there’s one thing for sure. An engagement ring is a personal choice. And while it’s important to hear voices expressing regret in their decisions, ultimately, the choice is yours. You should wear a ring that makes you feel special and signifies the love you share with your significant other

Our Methodology

We began by compiling a comprehensive list of engagement ring styles and diamond shapes. This list was sourced from industry documentation and reputable references to ensure it accurately reflected the range of available designs.

To identify relevant consumer discussions, we conducted targeted searches on Reddit. We used automation tools to scrape comments that mentioned each ring style, allowing us to gather insights from a diverse range of user experiences and perspectives.

Our analysis focused on detecting expressions of regret within Reddit comments. We identified key indicators of buyer’s remorse by searching for specific keywords and phrases such as “regret,” “it was a mistake,” and “wish I didn’t get it.” These keywords, along with their variations, were systematically recorded in a table to ensure consistency in capturing language related to regret.

You can find the list of regret-related keywords we used below: